The Historical Critical Method Of Bible Interpretation

Over the years, scholars have been debating the validity of using the historical-critical method in Lutheran seminaries, in the context of Scripture interpretation. Some scholars, who prefer Martin Luther’s grammatical-critical method, are concerned that the historical-critical method creates an environment of doubt and confusion. I will evaluate and review two articles that pertain to this subject, The Historical-Critical Method of Bible Interpretation written by Seigert W. Becker and Higher Criticism and the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America written by Richard A. Krause. In addition, I will analyze Timothy Ward’s book Words of Life and Dr. Francis Martin’s contribution to Carl, Scott ed. Verbum Domini and the Complimentarity of Exegesis and Theology, in order to formulate my theology of Holy Scripture. Although, some scholars continue to use the historical-critical method, other scholars believe that it is a failing method, which undermines the authority a nd veracity of Scripture. Becker expounds his views against the historical-critical method. Siegert W. Becker According to Becker, it is undeniable that those who use the historical-critical method do so while believing that men wrote the Holy Scripture in a historical content. Therefore, scholars must study Scriptures with a critical thinking cap to determine whether everything these men wrote are the facts. 2 Furthermore, Becker believed that those who utilized the historical-critical method became theShow MoreRelatedThe Hebrew Bible, By Marc Zvi Brettler1390 Words   |  6 PagesJewish Bible, authored by Biblical scholar, and professor, Marc Zvi Brettler, is an enlightening text, guiding people towards studying the Hebrew Scriptures purposefully. Brettler (2005) reveals his book provides a response to the frustration many readers hold towards the Hebrew Bible, with the conventional tendency of filtering it through the lens of present-day culture. Generally, he argues, as a result, this leads one to misconstrue passages or arrive at the definitive conclusion the Bible holdsRead MoreSolo And Sola Scriptur Two Protestant Positions1461 Words   |  6 Pagesone is infallible in his interpretation of Scripture† (Mathison, 240). When something is infallible it is incapable of making mistakes or being wrong. Sola Scriptura is the teaching that the only infallible thing is the Bible. In both of these Scripture is a main part of the beliefs which is why the way that the Scripture is analyzed is important. Some of the traditions that come from traditions come from history and the origin of the Scripture. The Historical Critical Method is the comparing of textRead MoreThe New Testament : History, Literature, And Theology By M. Eugene Boring954 Words   |  4 Pagesoverview of the New Testament from a historical, literature and theological perspective. As stated by the author, this book does not attempt to work through every point in methodological detail, but from a case to case intends to provide enough specifics to illustrate evidence and argument (xxv). The author argues that the book is intended for the beginning student, presupposing only serious interest in the subject matter, but no prior experience in detailed Bible study (xxv). The author also arguesRead MoreThe Reading Of Christian Scripture Essay810 Words   |  4 PagesAny given Sunday, or anytime a gro up of Christian believers gather together, there is the reading of Christian Scripture. Additionally, there is an interpretation of said Scripture used to edify, guide, and confront the community listening to this Scripture. In the midst of this reading and interpretation, there is the liturgy. â€Å"This is the Word of the Lord. Thanks be to God.† Whether or not this liturgy is stated, there is an implicit posture that this Scripture read and interpreted is a word toRead MoreEssay on The Historical Critical Method2026 Words   |  9 Pagesand for nearly the same period of time people have struggled for the right interpretation of that what was written in these 27 books and letters. How should one handle a book that is Gods Word? Before looking at the pro and contra of historical-critical exegesis it is necessary to define this method. One of the many textbooks teaching the historical-critical method Methodenlehre zum Neuen Testament by Wilhelm Egger method gives us this definition, Diese Methoden lesen den Text vor allem unterRead MoreThe Truth Behind Exodus 8 Essay example2090 Words   |  9 PagesAt first glance a story of the Bible may appear to be just that, a simple story; however, when one does more than simply read the story, there are a plethora of underlying meanings to be found. Reading the Bible in search of its meanings can sometimes be confusing, which results in several different interpretations and raises many arguments amongst the readers. When reading the Bible, â€Å"it is necessary to apply tools of critical reading to find out what God wants to communicate with us,† (Smith-ChristopherRead MoreThe And Authority Of The New Testament Canon1079 Words   |  5 Pages The traditional interpretation of the development and authority of the New Testament canon is often a topic of debate and scrutiny; however, Dr. Michael J. Kruger provided an excellent, well-written justification of how the New Testament canon came to be the 27 books known today. Kruger is President and the Samuel C. Patterson Professor of New Testament and Early Christianity at Reformed Theological Seminary in Charlotte, NC. Other publications include The Gospel of the Savior, The Question ofRead More`` A Theology `` : Is Christian Theology A Pile Of Dead Bones?1011 Words   |  5 Pagesthem as disconnected as ever. The challenges of nihilism and the historical-critical method appear to have severed the historical ties that the Church once had to mainstream culture. Through the modern framework of a divorce of culture and church, Robert Jenson, in his book, A Theology in Outline: Can These Bones Live?, deconstructs and illustrates various theological concepts in an attempt to answ er the greater theological and historical question within his subtitle: is Christian theology a pile ofRead MoreEarly American Children s Literature1490 Words   |  6 Pageseducation. Puritans were one of the first groups to create a large body of children s books, their doctrine of original sin assumed that all children were damned until they were converted to Christianity (Susina ). The Puritans believed that reading the Bible was important to achieving salvation, therefore teaching children to read was a priority for that matter. The New England Primer, An Alphabet of Lessons For Children, was strongly influenced by religion and had the intentions that all the colonistsRead MoreHermeneutics3982 Words   |  16 PagesHERMENEUTICS AS A METHOD OF TEXT-INTERPRETATION Hermeneutics means the theory of interpretation, i.e. thetheory of achieving an understanding of texts, utterances, and so on (it does notmean a certain twentieth-century philosophical movement). It is the art of interpreting. Hermeneutics proved to be much bigger than theology or legal theory. The comprehension of any written text requires hermeneutics; reading a literary text is as much a hermeneutic act as interpreting law or Scripture. Without